Low prices don't buy client loyalty — I learned this the hard way

Question

Early on I gave a client the lowest price I've ever offered for a season of treatments — well below what I charge now. I wasn't just trying to be nice — I was pushing hard to hit a client count target and wanted every renewal I could get.

It didn't work out the way I planned.

Throughout the season he kept asking about problems I couldn't solve — mushrooms growing from a tree stump that was never ground down, issues with his neighbor that had nothing to do with lawn care. I explained multiple times there's no treatment that fixes a stump that's still in the ground. The conversations got more frustrating for both of us.

Eventually I decided I was done. When I sent a follow-up email, his response was that he'd already found someone else anyway.

The price didn't buy loyalty. It didn't even buy patience. The clients who leave for a cheaper option were never really yours to keep — and discounting to hit a number just delays the inevitable while costing you margin and energy.

I don't offer that price anymore. And I'm not chasing that type of client either.

Compare that to today. A new client paid $300 for a first visit and is looking at a $1,500 lawn restoration plan, small lawn. No pushback on price — just a good conversation with someone who wanted their problem actually solved, where many other companies have failed before. Before I even showed up he'd already talked to his neighbor about my service. The neighbor enrolled without questioning the price either. By the end of the day both were happy and grateful.

A few days apart. Two completely different types of clients. The difference wasn't the lawn — it was the price point that attracted them in the first place.

wolfcubjr · Answer

I have learned the hard way of taking every job -just to have a job. I’ve become much more selective about who I work with to protect my time and energy. I make more money in the end when attracting the clients I want instead of chasing and bending my structure (price reductions, saying yes when I should say no, etc.) to obtain just anyone who’ll hire me.&nbsp;

roselvaggio · Answer

When I first started my business, I was terrified of raising prices.

I thought if I was the cheapest company in town, clients would stay forever. So I’d underprice jobs, hesitate to increase rates, and bend over backward to “keep people happy.”

It didn’t work.

The clients who left over a $10 or $20 increase weren’t loyal to begin with. They were loyal to the lowest price.

Meanwhile, the clients who valued reliability, professionalism, communication, and consistency stayed with us even through multiple price increases.

Ironically, charging more also allowed us to offer better pay, better benefits, stronger training, and a more consistent experience for the clients who actually appreciated what we provided.

Now, when someone says, “The other company is cheaper,” I genuinely wish them the best.

Because I finally learned that competing on price attracts people who will leave for… price.

Forum Discussion

Low prices don't buy client loyalty — I learned this the hard way

2 Replies