Are You Selling Your Service… or Selling the Experience?
Customers have more choices than ever. Sometimes the difference isn’t just the service you provide, but how you make people feel from the first interaction to the final follow-up. What are some ways your business creates an experience that keeps customers coming back?Are reviews more useful than a marketing agency?
I’ve been thinking about this a lot lately. A good marketing agency can absolutely help a business. They can help with creative, targeting, campaigns, landing pages, reporting, and getting ads in front of the right people. But before you pay someone to write your message, it’s probably worth asking: Have you actually studied what your customers already said about you? Because your reviews may be one of the most useful marketing assets in your business. A lot of owners look at reviews as proof. 5 stars. Good testimonial. Nice thing to put on the website. That’s useful, but it’s only the surface. The better part is the language. Customers will tell you exactly why they hired you, what they were afraid of, what they noticed, what made them trust you, what almost stopped them from buying, and what made them stay. For us, reading through our reviews changed how I thought about our marketing. Customers kept repeating things like: “worth every penny” “one less thing to worry about” “like clockwork” “they text before they come” “they send a picture of the closed gate” “they take the waste with them” “I was embarrassed” “my last company left the gate open” “there aren’t enough hours in the day” That language is better than anything I could have guessed from sitting at my desk. It showed me the real buying triggers. Some people hired us because the yard got away from them over winter or they're busy families who didn’t have time. Others had health issues, pregnancy, injuries, or physical limitations. A small handful switched from cheaper competitors because they were tired of missed visits, poor communication, or gates being left open. Those details matter. If I only market the task, I sound like every other company. “We scoop dog poop.” That’s true, but it doesn’t explain why someone is willing to pay a premium. The reviews showed us what people actually valued: Communication. Reliability. Thoroughness. Gate safety. Waste hauled away. Professional scheduling. No judgment when the yard is bad. A clean yard without having to think about it. That becomes ad copy, website copy, quote follow-up language, sales training, social proof and also helps with pricing objections. When customers repeatedly say “worth every penny,” “more than fair,” or “I’d pay twice as much,” that tells me price is not the full story for the right buyer. It tells me I need to explain the value better, not panic and discount the service every time someone asks about price. A marketing agency can miss that if they don’t understand the business deeply enough. They may write clean copy, but clean copy doesn’t always match the customer’s internal conversation. Your reviews give you that conversation. They tell you what people were already thinking before they bought or what made them feel safe enough to hire you. They show you which parts of the experience matter more than you realized. For us, gate photos became a bigger marketing point because customers kept mentioning them. Hauling waste away became a bigger marketing point because customers kept comparing that to companies that leave it in their trash can. Communication became one of our strongest selling points because people brought it up over and over again. That’s the kind of information every business owner should be paying attention to. Before you rewrite your ads, rebuild your website or hire someone to "fix your marketing", read your reviews. Print them out. Tag the repeated phrases. Look for patterns. Group them by pain point, objection, trust factor, and reason they stayed. Then use the customer’s language in your marketing. Your best customers are often telling you exactly how to sell to more people like them. Have you ever gone through your reviews and pulled out the exact phrases customers keep repeating?How Often Should Home Service Businesses Market to Their Existing Customers?
I recently started a discussion asking: "What's one Jobber feature you wish you had started using sooner?" One response really stood out to me. The member mentioned that while many businesses use Jobber to manage jobs, schedules, quotes, and invoices, one feature that often gets overlooked is the Marketing Suite. The point they made was simple but powerful: Many of us do a great job serving customers, but we don't always stay connected with them after the work is done. Instead of only reaching out when it's time to sell something, sending regular educational emails and staying active on social media helps keep your business top of mind. When customers eventually need your services again, or know someone who does they're much more likely to remember you. They also shared that Jobber's upcoming Marketing Calendar will make planning emails and social posts much easier, especially for teams that collaborate on marketing. It got me thinking, How many of us already have a list of past customers but rarely communicate with them? A simple monthly email with seasonal tips, maintenance reminders, or homeowner advice could be enough to keep those relationships alive. I'm curious: How often do you market to your existing customers, and what's worked best for you? I'd love to hear what others are doing.Are you using your customer reviews to improve your marketing?
I recently had Claude scrape and organize all of our Google and Facebook reviews, then I put the findings into ACQ AI to see what needed to change in our business context, avatar, offer, and marketing. It was honestly one of the more useful marketing exercises I’ve done. Because the reviews showed what customers actually care about. For us, the strongest themes were: communication reliability thoroughness gate safety haul-away professionalism being kind to customers and their dogs Some of that I already knew. But seeing it repeated across hundreds of reviews made it a lot harder to ignore. For example, customers mention our text communication constantly. They like knowing when we’re coming. They like the 30-minute heads up. They like the “all done” message. They like getting a picture of the closed gate. That tells me communication is a major part of the service experience. Customers also bring up gate safety a lot. That matters because many of them have either had a dog get out before or they’re afraid it could happen. So if I’m writing ads, emails, or website copy, I probably need to talk about safety and gate photos more often. Another big one was haul-away. We take the waste with us instead of leaving it in the customer’s trash can. I’ve always seen that as part of our service, but the reviews showed customers notice it and care about it. That becomes a marketing point. The review analysis also confirmed something important about price. We are on the higher end in our market. Customers still say things like: worth every penny more than fair I’d pay twice as much That tells me our marketing should not be built around being cheap. It should explain why the service is worth more: better communication safer access cleaner yards less smell less stress more trust I think more home service businesses should do this. Your reviews can show you: Why people hired you in the first place Were they overwhelmed? Burned by another company? Too busy? Embarrassed? Dealing with a life event? Why they stayed Was it communication? Quality? Reliability? The technician? The process? What they say when price is no longer the main issue Those exact phrases should influence your ads, website, emails, and sales scripts. What your unique selling proposition actually is Sometimes the thing customers love most is different than the thing you keep promoting. Where your systems are creating trust or friction One bad review about repeated follow-up texts told us something important too. Automation has to respect opt-outs and avoid making people feel chased. The biggest takeaway for me: Your best marketing language is probably already sitting inside your reviews. You just have to organize it, look for patterns, and let the customer tell you why they chose you. Have you ever gone through your reviews and changed your marketing based on what customers were already saying?Are cheap competitors actually your fault?
This is probably going to rub some people the wrong way, but I think it’s worth talking about. A lot of service business owners complain about cheap competitors. I get it. There is always someone willing to do the work for less. In my industry, I’ve seen people charge prices that make no sense once you factor in drive time, labor, supplies, fuel, insurance, taxes, and the actual time it takes to do the job right. But I also think we have to be honest as business owners. If the only thing a customer understands about your service is the task itself, they are going to compare you against the cheapest version of that task. For us, that would be: “They scoop dog poop.” So the customer starts comparing: price frequency who can come sooner who seems cheaper That’s a weak position to be in. The customer has no reason to value the difference because we haven’t explained the difference well enough. That’s where positioning matters. For us, we had to get much better at explaining what the customer is actually paying for: proactive communication reminders before service on-the-way messages gate photos after every visit waste hauled away thorough multi-pass yard checks professional invoicing and scheduling reliable weekly service trained and background checked technicians a company that shows up consistently Those things matter to our best customers. And when we looked through our reviews, customers were already telling us that. They were saying things like: “worth every penny” “like clockwork” “one less thing to worry about” “they text before they come” “they send a picture of the closed gate” “they take the waste with them” “our last company left the gate open” That changed how I thought about cheap competitors. Some customers will always choose the cheapest option. That’s fine. But if too many good-fit customers are comparing you only on price, your message may not be doing enough work. Your marketing should make it clear why your service costs what it costs before the customer ever asks. That means talking about: risk trust reliability communication safety convenience consistency the cost of hiring the wrong company The cheaper competitor may still win some customers. But I don’t want to lose the right customers because I failed to explain why we’re different. Are cheap competitors hurting your business, or is your positioning making it too easy for customers to compare you on price?How are you offsetting seasonal churn in your business?
We’re in the part of the year where churn can start creeping up. For us, summer can be weird. People travel more. Kids are home. Budgets get tighter. Some customers pause because they think they’ll “just handle it themselves for a while.” Then a few weeks later the yard gets away from them again. I’ve been thinking a lot about how to reduce that churn before it happens instead of only reacting after someone cancels. A few things we’re working on right now: bulk prepayment offers more customer engagement through our physical newsletter promoting add-on services reactivation campaigns for past clients downselling instead of immediately accepting cancellations The downselling piece has been important. If a customer reaches out to cancel because of finances, I don’t always want the only option to be “stay or leave.” Sometimes there’s a middle option. For example, moving them to a lower frequency for a season may keep the relationship alive and still keep their yard from getting completely out of control. That’s better than losing them entirely and having to reacquire them later. We’re also sending more prepayment offers because it helps with cash flow and gives customers a reason to commit ahead of time. The physical newsletter has helped too. It keeps the relationship warmer. Customers hear from us outside of invoices, appointment reminders, and service texts. That matters because recurring customers are easier to lose when the business only talks to them transactionally. I’m also paying more attention to which customers are most at risk of canceling: price-sensitive customers lower-frequency customers customers who pause seasonally people who have recently had schedule changes customers who haven’t used add-on services past clients who canceled but may still need help This is one of those areas where I think service businesses need more than just new leads. You need a retention plan. What are you doing to offset seasonal churn before customers cancel?Are clients buying the visible work, or the judgement behind it?
I am building a small dog training business, and one thing I keep coming back to is that clients often see only the visible part of the service. In my case, that might look like a walk, a training session, or some handling work outside. But the real value is not just the visible activity. It is the assessment, the judgement, the reading of the dog, the owner coaching, the risk control, and knowing when not to push further. I imagine this applies across a lot of home service businesses. A client may see the mowing, cleaning, repair, landscaping, or installation, but not always the planning, experience, insurance, equipment, decision-making, or risk carried by the business. That creates a marketing problem. If we only describe the visible task, clients compare us against the cheapest version of that task. If we explain the judgement behind the work, we have a better chance of being compared on value rather than price alone. For those further along, how have you explained the “invisible value” of your work without sounding defensive or overcomplicated?
