Anyone else realize they were breaking even or losing money after expenses?

Question

I had a phase where we looked “busy” on paper, fully booked, money coming in, but when I actually broke down the numbers, some jobs were barely breaking even.

Once I factored in true payroll burden (taxes, workers comp), supplies, insurance, and transaction fees, it was a wake-up call. There were jobs we were doing that felt productive day-to-day but weren’t contributing to profit at all.

For us, it came down to tightening up pricing, being more intentional about which jobs we accepted, and really understanding our numbers on a per-job basis (not just overall revenue).

Curious if anyone else has gone through this and what changes made the biggest impact for you?

contractorcpa · Answer

It’s a painful but necessary realization. We call it "Margin Fade." You feel productive because the trucks are moving, but the bank account stays flat.

We've found it helpful to include an overhead allocation on the Job reports. It shifts the focus from "How much revenue can we hit?" to "How much are we keeping?" It's a useful exercise for any business to go through because you start to get a better grasp around what jobs are actually worth pursuing.

hilltopados · Answer

This is one of the most common traps in service businesses and it usually starts at the quote stage, not the job stage. By the time you're breaking down a completed job and finding the margin problem, the damage is already done.

The shift that tends to make the biggest difference is building your actual cost burden into the quoting formula before the job is ever sold. Not as a gut check after the fact, but as a hard floor the quote has to clear. Payroll burden, overhead allocation, transaction fees, all of it priced in by default.

The other piece is job mix. Once you have per-job margin visibility you start seeing which categories are consistently thin and which ones carry the business. A lot of operators find that 20% of their job types are generating most of the real profit and the rest is just keeping the trucks moving.

What did your pricing adjustment look like practically? Did you raise across the board or start being selective about job types?

judithvirag · Answer

I hired a Fractional CFO about two years ago.&nbsp; I have been in business for 17 years and finally got to the phase of educating myself about finances.&nbsp; We worked on a lot of strategies.&nbsp; Now we evaluate our pricing every quarter and for the clients we need to raise we will.&nbsp; Another big realization was what is the revenue amount we bring each month and if it is above a certain amount then our profit increases a lot.&nbsp; I know these realizations might be normal for some but they were lightbulb moments for me.&nbsp;

Forum Discussion

Anyone else realize they were breaking even or losing money after expenses?

3 Replies