Having Staff in House vs a Staffing Agency
I've come across a lot of interesting problems in the 4 years of my business. None has been more complicated as staffing. Who we hire, how we hire the, cadence of feedback, staying on top of write ups, etc etc. I've really been having trouble with finding qualified carpenters to work for us and was approached by a staffing company. They find the people, they live on their payroll and they charge you an all in mark up that includes workers comp and payroll taxes. The mark up if they find the person is 60%.
If you import all your own people over to them, they just mark up the labor 40%.
The latter seemed really interesting because my typical burden rate is like 35% and for 5% more, I'm de-risking myself.
But what are the unintended consequences of this?
Are my people going to feel like I'm off loading them? What am I not seeing here?
My initial thought is moving my payroll over would be a win. I had a workers comp claim from a couple years ago that caused me to almost lose my license and it was totally bogus, but my hands were tied. Also, if I hire someone and it doesn't work out, they just "re-assign" them. Also they mentioned that if we are slow, maybe one of their other clients needs help so it helps get the guys their hours.
What do you all think of this? Good idea or bad idea?