Forum Discussion

Lisa's avatar
Lisa
Jobber Community Team
28 days ago

When a customer says, "That's too expensive," how do you respond?

What’s your go-to move when a customer pushes back on price? Do you ask a follow-up question? Offer different options? When do you know to walk away?

In this episode of Masters of Home Service, Kevin Cook and Rob Soper explain how:

  • "Too expensive" usually isn't about price, it's about trust and value
  • Asking the right questions beats defending your price
  • Giving options (like good, better, best pricing) changes the conversation

Want to put these tips into action? Download our free guide to handling price objections (includes scripts).

Never miss an episode of Masters of Home Service. Subscribe on Apple, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts.

7 Replies

  • I always go back to a line I had a trainer say to client in front of me more than 13 years ago,

    "I am not too expensive, you just don't see the value"

    I still use that line today. Sometimes when I get the vibe that someone was expecting a lower price I can't wait to drop that line on them because of how it changes their approach to the conversation.

    • Lisa's avatar
      Lisa
      Jobber Community Team

      Helping customers see the value behind the price is key. Even a quick explanation of what’s included and the results they can expect can really shift the conversation. Thanks for sharing! :)

  • tbarth's avatar
    tbarth
    Contributor 3

    I usually respond with empathy and try to subtly shift control back to them.

    Something like:

    “I totally understand, it’s still money going out. If you decide to move forward at some point and would like to have us do the work, we’d be happy to look at adjusting the scope, scheduling it a bit later, or splitting the payment to make it easier.”

    The key for me is the order. I acknowledge the reality of spending money, but I don’t defend the pricing or agree that it’s “too expensive.” Then I frame everything in the future, “if you decide to move forward,” so it doesn’t sound like I’m trying to overcome an objection or sell them on a workaround.

    That gives them space. If they mean “compared to your competition,” they can say that. If it’s an affordability thing they don’t want to voice, they don’t have to. And by prefacing the options that way, it lets them be the one to say, “Actually, if you can split it…” instead of me pushing it.

    It keeps things empathetic and cooperative without negotiating against myself.

    It's not a one size fits all tack, but it's where I typically start.

    At the end of the day, most people are just people. When they bring up price, they’re often bracing for pushback. A little empathy and a cooperative tone usually go a long way.  And if they still get grumpy, that was likely going to happen no matter what. At least this way I haven’t taken the bait or escalated it. 

    • cedarsmithhomes's avatar
      cedarsmithhomes
      Contributor 2

      This approach seems like a great way give your customers some relief. Not being defensive used to be difficult for me. I like the way you approach it.

    • Lisa's avatar
      Lisa
      Jobber Community Team

      I love how you lead with empathy and frame the decision in a cooperative way. It's a solid and smart approach to keep things calm, give them space, and avoid negotiating against yourself! Thanks for breaking it down (+ sharing your script and thoughtful reminders when it comes to selling) :)

  • FredHodgeJr's avatar
    FredHodgeJr
    Jobber Ambassador

    When a customer says, “That’s too expensive,” they’re almost never talking about money.

    They’re usually saying one of three things:
    • I don’t see the value
    • I wasn’t expecting that number
    • I’m not fully confident yet

    If your first move is to discount, you just validated their doubt.

    Do not defend.
    Do not justify.
    Do not drop price immediately.

    Slow the moment down and take control of the conversation.

    Ask: “When you say it’s too expensive, compared to what?”

    Now you’re diagnosing instead of reacting.

    If they mention another company, respond with:

    “Are they offering the same scope, warranty and process?”

    Force the comparison beyond price. Most cheaper quotes remove something. Scope. Prep work. Insurance. Warranty. Follow-up. That’s where value lives.

    If they say, “It’s more than we wanted to spend,” say:

    “Got it. Is the hesitation about the investment itself, or does the scope feel bigger than what you were hoping for?”

    Now you’ve separated budget from expectations.

    From there, you have three strong plays:

    Re-anchor the value
    Bring them back to the problem.

    “What happens if this doesn’t get addressed this season?”
    “What would it cost you if this gets worse?”

    Pain clarifies priority. Urgency creates movement.

    Offer controlled options
    Not a discount. A scope adjustment.

    “We could break this into phases.”
    “If we removed X, that would bring it to Y.”

    You stay in control. You adjust the plan, not your standards.

    Hold your ground
    “If we’re not the right fit at this level, I completely understand. We’re probably not the cheapest option, but we are the company that does it once and does it right.”

    Confidence closes more deals than coupons ever will.

    When do you walk away?

    You walk when:
    • They are only shopping for the lowest number
    • They negotiate before understanding value
    • They don’t respect expertise
    • The margin becomes unhealthy

    • Lisa's avatar
      Lisa
      Jobber Community Team

      This is such a great breakdown, Fred! You’re spot on that “too expensive” usually isn’t about the number itself. It’s about confidence, expectations, or comparison. Slowing the moment down instead of reacting is such a powerful shift.

      I also really like the points you made about knowing when to walk away. It's true, not every job is the right fit, and being clear on your standards and margins is huge for long-term success.

      Thanks so much for sharing. Really awesome perspective and scripts for anyone having these conversations regularly!